Open-Mindedness

What Open-Mindedness means when using AI

The generated handover summary says the workplace project is ready. Its sentences have the satisfying finality of a door clicking shut. A colleague begins an awkward objection: “The labels—the boxes—there’s still...” The report sounds much more certain. You ask them to finish. The printed labels have not arrived, so the packed materials cannot yet be handed over as described. You examine that point before forwarding the summary. One unfinished sentence has reopened a finished-looking report.

Open-Mindedness gives…

The account can benefit from knowledge held by the people doing the work. An awkward contribution receives a chance to prevent a premature handover or establish that the apparent problem has already been resolved.

Finding the balance

Hearing a reason does not commit you to accepting it. Ask a question that could change your judgment, then decide what the evidence supports; confidence of delivery is not the deciding test.

In ordinary life

A study group

Let a classmate explain why an elegant generated solution may have missed a condition.

A work recommendation

Ask the person who will use the result to explain the practical objection before answering it.

Nearby virtues, different work

Humility

Humility acknowledges what you may not know; Open-Mindedness gives another person’s account a hearing.

Intellectual Honesty

Intellectual Honesty revises an established belief when the considered evidence warrants it.

Recognizing a counterfeit

A counterfeit of Open-Mindedness is collecting objections only to polish the rebuttal. State what would count in favor of the colleague’s concern and allow the answer to affect your next step.

How to cultivate Open-Mindedness

• Give an interrupted or awkward objection time to become clear.
• Restate its strongest relevant point before evaluating it.
• Identify what would confirm, resolve or overturn the concern.

Try it today

Use a fictional handover note that says all materials are ready and a colleague’s note that the labels have not arrived. Write one fair question and identify what information would settle the concern. This is a private reasoning exercise, not a requirement to challenge someone at work.

Questions worth returning to

• Am I answering the objection or its awkward delivery?
• What information could make this person’s reason change the report?

Choose your practice

The situations on these pages are illustrative. These pages offer ideas for reflection and character practice, not professional advice. Choose practices suited to your circumstances and abilities. You may adapt, pause, or skip an exercise; putting yourself or someone else at risk is not proof of virtue.

Quotations and further reading

Read these passages in their original settings through the source links.

1. Hands off: neither the whole of truth nor the whole of good is revealed to any single observer, although each observer gains a partial superiority of insight from the peculiar position in which he stands.

   William James, Talks to Teachers on Psychology; and to Students on Some of Life’s Ideals
   II. on a Certain Blindness in Human Beings · excerpt

   James gives each observer a possible advantage of position while denying that any one sees the whole. A colleague’s particular experience can matter even when a summary sounds more comprehensive.

2. But I could not help feeling, that though the tone was unbecoming (an error for which the writer, at a later period, made the most ample and honourable amends), there was truth in several of his strictures on my father's treatment of the subject; that my father's premises were really too narrow, and included but a small number of the general truths on which, in politics, the important consequences depend.

   John Stuart Mill, Autobiography
   Chapter V — Crisis in My Mental History. One Stage Onward · excerpt

   Mill acknowledges grounds in an attack on his father despite its objectionable tone. Delivery and the merits of the reason remain separate matters for judgment.

3. Another error, of a diverse nature from all the former, is the over-early and peremptory reduction of knowledge into arts and methods; from which time commonly sciences receive small or no augmentation.

   Francis Bacon, The Advancement of Learning
   Book I · excerpt

   Bacon warns that fixing knowledge prematurely into a method can halt its growth. A settled-looking handover should remain open to a relevant fact its structure missed.

4. Isabella’s opinion of the Tilneys did not influence her friend; she was sure there had been no insolence in the manners either of brother or sister; and she did not credit there being any pride in their hearts.

   The narrator, in Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey
   Chapter 16 · excerpt

   Catherine does not adopt Isabella’s uncharitable reading of the Tilneys. Listening to another account leaves room to assess it against what one has actually observed.

5. Then only can he see that what is unpleasant to us is not necessarily unbeautiful, but has its beauty in truth.

   Rabindranath Tagore, Sadhana: The Realisation of Life
   The Realisation of Beauty · excerpt ·
   English arrangement by Rabindranath Tagore; preface credits translated passages to Satish Chandra Roy and Ajit Kumar Chakravarti, with revisions by Ernest Rhys; individual passage shares unspecified.

   Tagore separates a thing’s beauty from whether it happens to please the observer. An unwelcome observation may reveal something worth attending to before it is dismissed.

6. The only thing to be dreaded in the Settlement is that it lose its flexibility, its power of quick adaptation, its readiness to change its methods as its environment may demand.

   Jane Addams, Twenty Years at Hull-House with Autobiographical Notes
   Chapter VI · excerpt

   Addams identifies flexibility and responsiveness as necessary to a Settlement’s work. Hearing the people who encounter a method is part of keeping it answerable to its purpose.

7. I am equally balked by antagonism and by compliance. Let him not cease an instant to be himself.

   Ralph Waldo Emerson, Friendship
   Friendship · excerpt

   Emerson rejects both reflexive opposition and mere compliance in friendship. A hearing has value when the other person remains free to bring a distinct judgment.

Continue through the catalog