Sincerity

Express your considered view when agreeable pretense would win easier approval.

Readiness to express one's actual convictions and intentions without pretense.

Sincerity makes what you say answerable to what you actually think and intend. Considerate company can accommodate a view that differs. When agreement becomes an admission ticket, a polished answer may conceal the person everyone hoped to meet.

Try a practice

Two seated mascots discuss books at a small table; the orange reader holds an open book and gestures while the grey reader smiles thoughtfully.

An ordinary choice

At a book group, you have prepared a lovely compliment about the ending. There is one difficulty: you do not believe it. You enjoyed the journey but cannot see why the detective suddenly became the gardener. You say both things. Someone else laughs with recognition, and the discussion finally has a question to work with.

An invented illustrative scene.

Sincerity gives…

Sincerity gives conversation something real to work with. Others can respond to your reasons, and you can discover whether disagreement helps you see more. An agreeable fiction supplies neither person with that opportunity.

What Sincerity makes possible

A woman’s contribution can include enthusiasm, doubt, humor and a considered objection. Saying what you mean need not mean speaking at every opportunity. Choosing a fitting moment and a limited claim can make sincerity easier to understand.

Sincerity: finding the balance

Too little

Agreeable pretense: praise the ending because the table seems unanimous. The group hears another vote it never truly received.

A fitting response

Sincere contribution: describe the passage you enjoyed and the ending that troubled you. Your actual response enters the discussion.

Pursued too far

Compulsory candor: announce every unfavorable reaction without regard to its purpose or audience. Disclosure becomes an appetite for impact.

The thoughtful answer may contain warmth and disagreement together. Sincerity is about the intention expressed; tone alone cannot establish it.

Sincerity in ordinary life

Creative work

A woman gives a collaborator feedback she actually means, rather than supplying praise that will leave the next draft harder to improve.

A social conversation

Say that you do not know enough about a proposed plan to endorse it yet.

A familiar taste

Enjoy a popular activity honestly, even if independence would look more fashionable.

Nearby virtues, different work

Tact

Tact shapes a necessary truth so that dignity remains intact.

Courtesy

Courtesy gives disagreement ordinary consideration without requiring agreement.

Sincerity and its counterfeits

A counterfeit of Sincerity is rehearsed agreement described as “exactly my thought.” An honest answer can acknowledge that another person has just changed your mind.

Cruel frankness is a counterfeit of Sincerity when truth is used chiefly to injure. State the actual concern without inventing a duty to say every hurtful thing.

How to cultivate Sincerity

Distinguish an opinion, a wish and an answer designed for approval.
Give a reason you can stand behind.
Allow yourself to revise a view openly when new reasons arrive.

Try it today

In a freely chosen conversation about a book, film or hobby, share one opinion you actually hold with one specific reason. An imagined response works equally well.

Did you add a claim you did not mean to make the answer sound impressive?

Sincerity does not require private disclosure or disagreement in a threatening setting. Choose a setting where participation is voluntary.

Questions worth returning to

What do I mean, beneath this pleasing phrase?
Can I make the scope of my claim clearer?

Keep the practice proportionate

Sincerity does not require private disclosure or disagreement in a threatening setting. Choose a setting where participation is voluntary.

These pages offer ideas for reflection and character practice, not professional advice. Choose practices suited to your circumstances and abilities. You may adapt, pause, or skip an exercise; putting yourself or someone else at risk is not proof of virtue.

About these practices

Quotations and further reading

Seven readings, one for each day. All remain available here. Historical arguments and fictional dialogue are identified in their source notes.

… she never flattered, and did not praise them half enough; but whenever she did speak favourably of them, or anything belonging to them, they could be quite sure her approbation was sincere. …
Anne Brontë · Agnes Grey
(zero-based), exact span 351–540
Agnes reporting her pupils’ estimation · Linked Project Gutenberg historical English transcription preserved 4 October 2026; no first-print collation asserted
The pupils learn that Agnes’s favorable judgment is sincere because she does not flatter them. Their reported view lets approval mean something beyond a ready social response.
… May I say a few words? I want to say a few words about this matter. …
Sojourner Truth · Address at the Woman’s Rights Convention, Akron
(zero-based), exact span 4–71
Sojourner Truth, as reported by Marius Robinson · Marius Robinson report, Anti-Slavery Bugle, 21 June 1851, p. 4; University of Maryland transcription; not an authenticated recording
The Robinson report opens with Truth claiming room to contribute to the women’s-rights discussion. This is a reported 1851 speech, not a certified verbatim record; its claim to a voice makes honest participation more than agreeable silence.
… the making it a common every-day affair for women to reason and think and express their thought …
Anna Julia Cooper · A Voice from the South
(zero-based), exact span 77–172
Anna Julia Cooper · Authorial essays, Aldine Printing House, 1892; preserved English transcription
Cooper names women’s reasoning and expression as an effect of higher education. The surrounding essay assigns gendered social contributions; this selection supports actual thought without importing exclusive masculine or feminine virtues.
And may truth, unpolluted by prejudice, vanity or selfishness, be granted daily more and more as the due of inheritance, and only valuable conquest for us all!
Margaret Fuller · Woman in the Nineteenth Century
(zero-based), exact span 0–159
Margaret Fuller · Linked Project Gutenberg historical English transcription preserved 4 October 2026; no first-print collation asserted
Fuller asks for truth free of vanity and prejudice. Her aspiration connects the expression of conviction with reconsideration rather than simply performing a pleasing view.
… Other Designs indeed Men may have, such as the Maintenance of their Own Opinions, Actions and Parties without regard to the Truth and Justice of ’em, or the Seduction of their unwary Neighbours, but these are Mean and Base ones, …
Mary Astell · A Serious Proposal to the Ladies
(zero-based), exact span 321–549
Mary Astell · Linked Project Gutenberg historical English transcription preserved 4 October 2026; no first-print collation asserted
Astell distinguishes inquiry and explanation from maintenance of a party regardless of truth. That distinction tests whether agreeable public words express a considered view.
Now I don’t believe in looking Honest people in the face, And saying when you’re doing wrong, That “I haven’t sold my race.”
Frances Ellen Watkins Harper · Sketches of Southern Life
Preserved stanza 78 (zero-based), exact span 0–124
Aunt Chloe, Harper’s fictional poetic narrator · 1891 Ferguson Bros. edition; Aunt Chloe sequence; preserved English verse with stanza boundaries
In Aunt Chloe’s Politics, the narrator rejects professions of loyalty that hide corrupt voting. The political context gives sincerity an accountable object, rather than another social compliment.
… entreated her to be open and sincere, and assured her that every inconvenience should be braved, and the connexion entirely given up, if she felt herself unhappy in the prospect of it. …
Jane Austen · Mansfield Park
(zero-based), exact span 93–277
Fictional narrator · Linked Project Gutenberg historical English transcription preserved 4 October 2026; no first-print collation asserted
Sir Thomas offers Maria an opportunity to be open about her proposed marriage. Her subsequent answer conceals her conflict. The invitation and its failure illuminate why agreement cannot be presumed to reflect intention.

Continue through the catalog

Practice this collection

Choose this approved collection as an optional workbook program, or select individual virtues in My Virtues.

Explore the program · Choose in My Virtues