Meliorating Virtues

Eighteen virtues to explore

The earlier website’s eighteen entries retain their original sequence. Each opens a complete reference article.

1. 1
   Tolerance — Share the space without requiring the same taste.
2. 2
   Reasonableness — Let the reasons improve the plan, including your own.
3. 3
   Tactfulness — Choose truthful words that leave another person room to respond.
4. 4
   Gentleness — Use the care and force the living situation requires.
5. 5
   Humorousness — Invite a shared laugh that leaves everyone their dignity.
6. 6
   Amiability — Make ordinary contact easy without promising unlimited attention.
7. 7
   Cheerfulness — Offer a little brightness that fits the moment.
8. 8
   Warmth — Let welcomed care show in a fitting gesture.
9. 9
   Appreciativeness — Notice the particular good, and say what it gives.
10. 10
    Openness — Make room for an unfamiliar person or possibility.
11. 11
    Even-temperedness — Keep your response proportionate when the little irritations gather.
12. 12
    Nonvindictiveness — Answer a wrong without adding a wrong of your own.
13. 13
    Civility — Keep disagreement answerable without making it contemptuous.
14. 14
    Politeness — Use familiar forms to spare another person needless awkwardness.
15. 15
    Decency — Keep another person’s dignity in view, even when nobody applauds.
16. 16
    Modesty — Let your contribution be seen at its actual size.
17. 17
    Hospitableness — Arrange welcome around the guest’s actual comfort.
18. 18
    Unpretentiousness — Meet people through the thing itself, without a display of rank.

Different virtues, different questions

“Meliorating” means making things better. Here the focus is the manner of shared life: whether people can differ, contribute, receive a correction and find a comfortable place without needless friction or loss of dignity. The smallness of an act does not make its effect imaginary. A greeting, a measured answer or a cleared seat changes the encounter it belongs to.

The members do different work. Tolerance lets a difference remain; Openness invites an encounter with it. Civility makes disagreement answerable; Politeness supplies considerate forms. Appreciativeness notices a particular good, while Modesty keeps one’s own contribution at its honest size. Reading those differences can make a familiar choice more exact.

What this collection offers

The collection offers ways to shape everyday company without turning sociability into a moral exam. Its practices can make an arrival easier, a correction more usable or an inconvenience less quarrelsome. Their value lies in how people are treated, not in guaranteed popularity, constant cheer or a conflict-free home.

Virtues in ordinary life

At a shared meal, Hospitableness arranges a place, Warmth makes welcome felt, and Politeness helps a request become easy to answer. A simple breakfast can contain all three without becoming an elaborate ceremony.

During disagreement, Civility protects a hearing, Reasonableness considers the reasons, and Tactfulness helps a needed truth reach its recipient. The result can still be a firm refusal.

During ordinary friction, Even-temperedness keeps the event in proportion, Nonvindictiveness declines added injury, and Humorousness may offer a shared laugh when the moment welcomes it.

Working together without becoming identical

Welcome and freedom: make company inviting while leaving people room to decline, leave or express themselves differently.

Forms and purpose: a courtesy earns its place when it helps the encounter. A manner that establishes rank or prevents criticism needs reconsideration.

Brightness and honest feeling: a fitting pleasure can be offered while a difficulty remains real. Nobody owes cheer as proof of gratitude.

The earlier selection and this new edition

The recovered project archive names eighteen Meliorating Virtues. Its substantive source note cites Edmund L. Pincoffs’s Quandaries and Virtues: Against Reductivism in Ethics (University Press of Kansas, 1986), describing qualities that improve the tolerability and livability of common life. The overview and individual summaries themselves are placeholder text. No completed historical articles have been recovered.

This edition preserves the website’s selection and order while supplying independently written explanations, examples and original verse. It does not reproduce the archive’s long modern book excerpt or claim to be an authorized exposition of Pincoffs. The archived list also differs from the qualities named in its source passage; it is the earlier website’s selection, not a verified definitive taxonomy from the book.

This is a collection for reading and reflection. Its articles distinguish neighboring qualities without claiming that everyday words have rigid borders. Choose a practice that fits your circumstances and leave room for a different response when the situation changes.

Bibliographic record: Quandaries and Virtues

Bring a reading into ordinary life

Choose one article that speaks to an ordinary responsibility. Its exercise is an invitation to reflection, with room to adapt or decline it.

Quotations and further reading

These historical passages offer different philosophical and literary perspectives. Each note identifies its setting, point of comparison and relevant limits; none supplies an official definition of this virtue.

1. Potentially therefore every and any act is within the scope of morals, being a candidate for possible judgment with respect to its better-or-worse quality.

   John Dewey · Human Nature and Conduct

   I · , exact-print and territory review held.

   Dewey brings any act within possible moral consideration. A greeting or shared arrangement can matter without first becoming a dramatic ethical crisis.

2. For neither goodness nor generosity nor courtesy can exist, any more than friendship can, if they are not sought of and for themselves, but are cultivated only for the sake of sensual pleasure or personal advantage.

   Marcus Tullius Cicero · On Duties

   BOOK III THE CONFLICT BETWEEN THE RIGHT AND THE EXPEDIENT · Walter Miller, 1913

   Cicero places courtesy and friendship among goods sought for themselves. The collection’s manners concern how people are treated, rather than a technique for winning favors.

3. Even the most ordinary degree of kindness or beneficence, however, cannot, among equals, be extorted by force.

   Adam Smith · The Theory of Moral Sentiments

   CHAP. I. Comparison of those two virtues. · , exact-print and territory review held.

   Smith distinguishes ordinary beneficence from something that can be extorted. Welcome and brightness retain their value as voluntary contributions.

4. The awkwardness and constraint we experience when two standards of conventions and manners clash but feebly prefigure this deeper difference.

   Jane Addams · Democracy and Social Ethics

   FILIAL RELATIONS · , exact-print and territory review held.

   Addams notices the awkwardness when conventions meet. The collection asks how considerate intentions can survive differences in familiar forms.

5. Wordsworth was praised to me, in Westmoreland, for having afforded to his country neighbors an example of a modest household where comfort and culture were secured, without display.

   Ralph Waldo Emerson · The Conduct of Life

   The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Conduct of Life · , exact-print and territory review held.

   Emerson reports praise for Wordsworth’s modest household. Comfort and culture without display illuminate a welcome arranged around its use rather than its prestige.

6. I love a gay and civil wisdom, and fly from all sourness and austerity of manners, all repellent, mien being suspected by me:

   Michel de Montaigne · Essays

   CHAPTER V——UPON SOME VERSES OF VIRGIL · Charles Cotton translation, William Carew Hazlitt edition, 1877

   Montaigne expresses a preference for a lively, civil wisdom over repellent austerity. This personal taste opens a conversation about the humane texture of common life, not a rule requiring cheerful appearance.

7. The whole tenor of a conversation is a part of the meaning of each separate statement; the beginning and the end define and travesty the intermediate conversation.

   Robert Louis Stevenson · Virginibus Puerisque, and Other Papers

   IV.—TRUTH OF INTERCOURSE · , exact-print and territory review held.

   Stevenson treats the whole conversation as part of each statement’s meaning. Small forms and gestures matter through the encounter they help shape.

Continue your reading