Integrity

A choice during disruption

You have asked everyone to label borrowed equipment accurately. The last extension lead is yours, and its return label would be inconvenient to write. You write it anyway. Your excellent principle has finally reached the item it was most tempted to skip.

An invented illustrative scene.

Integrity gives…

Consistent action gives others firmer grounds for relying on your commitments. They need not guess whether a principle remains in force when it becomes inconvenient to its speaker.

What Integrity makes possible

A group’s arrangements can become more trustworthy through small congruent acts: accurate labels, kept limits and exceptions explained in the same terms for everyone.

Integrity: finding the balance

Integrity is consistency with considered convictions, not loyalty to every past decision. A reasoned correction may restore integrity where stubbornness would preserve only a record.

Integrity in ordinary life

A shared agreement

Observe the limit you proposed when using the shared room yourself.

An honest exception

Explain why a changed circumstance affects a rule and make the reason available to those affected.

Nearby virtues, different work

Honesty

Honesty keeps a representation from misleading; Integrity aligns deliberate conduct with considered convictions.

Fairness

Fairness examines due treatment across people; Integrity includes applying the resulting conviction to your own action.

Integrity and its counterfeits

Principle theater is a counterfeit of Integrity: elaborate declarations cannot substitute for the small inconvenient act they require.

Blind rule worship is a counterfeit when consistency becomes an excuse to disregard the ethical purpose of the rule.

How to cultivate Integrity

• Choose one conviction that has a practical consequence.
• Notice your favorite convenient exception.
• Distinguish a revised reason from an excuse invented afterward.

Try it today

Pick an agreement you freely accepted. Apply it to one small choice where compliance is inconvenient, or explain a sound reason for renegotiating it with those affected. Avoid situations involving coercion or retaliation.

Compare your explanation with what you would accept from another participant.

This practice does not require public confession, confrontation with an unsafe authority or disclosure of private information. Agreements made under coercion are not a character exercise.

Questions worth returning to

• Does this exception serve the principle or just me?
• What would justify revising the agreement for everyone?

Keep the practice proportionate

This practice does not require public confession, confrontation with an unsafe authority or disclosure of private information. Agreements made under coercion are not a character exercise.

These pages offer ideas for reflection and character practice, not professional advice. Choose practices suited to your circumstances and abilities. You may adapt, pause, or skip an exercise; putting yourself or someone else at risk is not proof of virtue.

Quotations and further reading

Seven readings, one for each day. All remain available here. Historical arguments and fictional dialogue are identified in their source notes.

1. … Our democracy has taught us to apply our moral teaching all around, and the moralist is rapidly becoming so sensitive that when his life does not exemplify his ethical convictions, he finds it difficult to preach.

   Jane Addams · Democracy and Social Ethics
   (zero-based); exact span 593–806
   Jane Addams · 1902 work; preserved current Project Gutenberg digital edition; first-print collation not asserted

   Addams makes the teacher’s own life answerable to the conviction being taught. The extension-lead rule begins to mean something when it inconveniences its advocate as well as everyone else.

2. … Indeed, part of the perplexity in the administration of charity comes from the fact that the type of person drawn to it is the one who insists that her convictions shall not be unrelated to action. …

   Jane Addams · Democracy and Social Ethics
   (zero-based); exact span 2015–2212
   Jane Addams · 1902 work; preserved current Project Gutenberg digital edition; first-print collation not asserted

   The helper’s conviction cannot stay separate from action. This is an account of motives in charity, not a claim that every charitable intervention is wise. A promise to follow the shared arrangement requires an actual choice.

3. … I dare say they'll be angry, but every man must do what he thinks to be the best for his country. …

   Anna Sewell · Black Beauty
   (zero-based); exact span 179–276
   Jerry Barker, in dialogue reported by Black Beauty · 1877 work; preserved current Project Gutenberg digital edition; first-print collation not asserted

   Jerry accepts possible disagreement rather than voting against his considered conscience. Integrity can have a personal cost even when others prefer a shortcut. The fictional election and its consequences are not an assigned political confrontation.

4. … If then we shall not also put in practice right opinions, we shall be nothing more than the expositors of the opinions of others. …

   Epictetus · A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus with the Encheiridion
   (zero-based); exact span 248–377
   Epictetus as transmitted by Arrian, in George Long’s translation · George Long translation; current Gutenberg 10661 transcription; exact first-print collation not asserted
   English translation by George Long

   Epictetus distinguishes practicing a judgment from merely explaining somebody else’s. Signing the tag can give the spoken principle a practical consequence. His philosophical training does not make dangerous self-testing a requirement.

5. … The Master said, 'The superior man wishes to be slow in his speech and earnest in his conduct. …

   Confucius · The Analects
   (zero-based); exact span 12–106
   Confucius, “the Master,” in Legge’s translation · Legge translation of The Chinese Classics; current Gutenberg 3330 transcription
   English translation by James Legge

   The passage pairs measured speech with earnest conduct. Let the use of your own property express the same commitment as your announcement. The ancient ideal’s gendered language is not a restriction on who can practice it.

6. … I keep harshness concealed, but I have clemency always at hand: I watch myself as carefully as though I had to give an account of my actions to those laws which I have brought out of darkness and neglect into the light of day. …

   Lucius Annaeus Seneca · Minor Dialogues, Together With the Dialogue on Clemency
   (zero-based); exact span 2069–2295
   Seneca’s imagined first-person statement for the ruler Nero in On Clemency · 1889 George Bell and Sons translation; current Gutenberg 64576 transcription
   English translation by Aubrey Stewart

   Seneca imagines power watching itself as carefully as it watches others. The imagined imperial speaker is part of his address to Nero, not Nero’s independently recorded testimony. A volunteer’s own compliance is the modest local parallel.

7. … Men that live upon pillage and borrowing, expose their purchases and buildings to every one’s view: but do not proclaim how they came by the money. …

   Michel de Montaigne · Essays
   (zero-based); exact span 1059–1206
   Michel de Montaigne · 1877 Cotton/Hazlitt edition; current Gutenberg 3600 transcription
   English translation by Charles Cotton; revised and edited by William Carew Hazlitt

   Montaigne contrasts the displayed purchase with the concealed means of obtaining it. He uses this financial analogy in discussing learning; the reader can also ask how a result was achieved. An impressive outcome does not make misleading or exploitative methods fit the conviction being claimed.

Continue through the catalog