Justice

A small heroic scene

The comic convention’s cleanup crew poses beside a mountain of collected confetti. You notice that the borrowed trolley still holds someone’s display boards. Returning them means missing the victory photograph. The boards belong to a person; the confetti has no objection to waiting for its portrait.

An invented illustrative scene.

Justice gives…

Justice makes protection answerable to the people it is meant to serve. Cleaning the hall is worthwhile, and returning the display boards is part of that worthwhile aftermath. Looking for the remaining claim gives success a more complete human meaning.

What Justice makes possible

After a fictional rescue, a story can ask who lost property, whose access was disrupted and whose needs remain. These questions need no invented legal authority. In shared activity, you can honor a return agreement, hear an overlooked participant or identify a cost your group has shifted onto someone else.

Justice: finding the balance

If two claims conflict, hear the relevant people and use the legitimate agreed route. A strong feeling that justice matters does not give you sole authority to settle it.

Justice in ordinary life

A completed project

Check whether a borrowed resource or promised acknowledgment remains outstanding.

An absent participant

Make room for a relevant claim that the group has found inconvenient to discuss.

Nearby virtues, different work

Fairness

Fairness weighs interests impartially; Justice keeps concern for what people are ethically due.

Mercy

Mercy considers leniency in a justified severe response; Justice keeps the affected people’s claims in view.

Justice and its counterfeits

Triumphant enforcement counterfeits Justice when a victory is treated as permission to punish or allocate other people’s property. Justice concerns what they are ethically due and respects the legitimate means of attending to those claims.

How to cultivate Justice

• Ask what remains owed after the headline result.
• Hear the person whose claim has become inconvenient.
• Use an agreed appropriate route for fulfilling it.

Try it today

After a shared task, check one outstanding agreement involving an object, time or contribution. Fulfill your part or arrange a realistic correction with the affected person. Do not investigate strangers or assume authority to punish.

Consider whose claim would have remained invisible if you had stopped at the group’s success.

Questions worth returning to

• What is still due after we declare success?
• Whose claim cannot compete with the celebration?

Keep the practice proportionate

These pages offer ideas for reflection and character practice, not professional advice. Choose practices suited to your circumstances and abilities. You may adapt, pause, or skip an exercise; putting yourself or someone else at risk is not proof of virtue.

Quotations and further reading

Seven readings, one for each day. All remain available here. Historical arguments and fictional dialogue are identified in their source notes.

1. Then, having used up the powers of the Golden Cap, I shall give it to the King of the Monkeys, that he and his band may thereafter be free for evermore.

   L. Frank Baum · The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
   “LET DOROTHY GO TO THE CITY OF EMERALDS” (zero-based)
   Glinda · Project Gutenberg 55 current HTML transcription; source typography preserved; first printing not collated

   Glinda’s plan includes freeing the Winged Monkeys after their service. The helpers’ own claim enters the ending instead of disappearing behind the travelers’ success.

2. We have come to realize that the great task of pushing forward social justice could be enormously accelerated if primitive methods as well as primitive weapons were once for all abolished.

   Jane Addams · Newer Ideals of Peace
   CHAPTER VIII PASSING OF THE WAR VIRTUES (zero-based)
   Jane Addams · Project Gutenberg 69879 current HTML transcription; source typography preserved; first printing not collated

   Addams challenges the means used in a cause described as just. The passage invites the hero to examine whether a celebrated method attends to the claims it says it protects.

3. If I devote myself to other pursuits and contemplations, I must first see, at least, that I do not pursue them sitting upon another man’s shoulders.

   Henry David Thoreau · On the Duty of Civil Disobedience
   (zero-based)
   Henry David Thoreau · Project Gutenberg 71 current HTML transcription; source typography preserved; first printing not collated

   The image tests whose burden makes a preferred pursuit possible. Thoreau’s political argument is the source context; the ordinary question here concerns the legitimate claim hidden beneath someone else’s achievement.

4. Society, to profit by this service, must insure right provision for the individual.

   Charlotte Perkins Gilman · Human Work
   XV CONSUMPTION (II) (zero-based)
   Charlotte Perkins Gilman · Project Gutenberg 64098 current HTML transcription; source typography preserved; first printing not collated

   Gilman argues that the person contributing service also has a claim to support. The normative proposal asks a heroic story to notice the contributor’s needs beyond the benefit others receive.

5. … to bear in mind that to prove it is as much the business of the judge as that of the prisoner …

   Seneca · Minor Dialogues, Together with the Dialogue on Clemency
   THE FIRST BOOK OF THE DIALOGUE OF L. ANNAEUS 380 SENECA, ADDRESSED TO NERO CAESAR. ON CLEMENCY. (zero-based)
   Seneca · 1889 George Bell and Sons; Aubrey Stewart translation; Project Gutenberg 64576 HTML display edition
   Latin original, English translation

   Seneca identifies a claim of the person subject to judgment before he turns to clemency. Justice requires due consideration; mercy concerns a justified response whose severity might be reduced.

6. … to be strictly just, it must have the sanction and consent of the governed.

   Henry David Thoreau · On the Duty of Civil Disobedience
   (zero-based)
   Henry David Thoreau · Project Gutenberg 71 current HTML transcription; source typography preserved; first printing not collated

   Thoreau questions the legitimacy of government power. The historical political argument brings the governed into an account that could otherwise dwell only on the authority’s own purpose.

7. Such a law is not only unjust, but it will react, as all unjust laws do, in time …

   Booker T. Washington · Up from Slavery: An Autobiography
   UP FROM SLAVERY (zero-based)
   Booker T. Washington · Project Gutenberg 2376 current HTML transcription; source typography preserved; first printing not collated

   Washington criticizes unequal voting requirements for Black and white citizens. The claim of injustice matters without relying on his prediction that injustice will inevitably rebound on those who create it.

Continue through the catalog